Home
Local News
Business & Economy
Business & the Law
Art & Culture
Interview
In Brief
Editorial
Feature
Perspective
Society
Comment
Focus
Environment
Sport
About us
Archives
 
   
 
 

 

 

The plan becomes elusive vision

By Tesfu Telahoun

Time, Newsweek, The Economist and other high circulation periodicals such as The New York Times almost regularly feature a section profiling the country that is commissioning the special advertisement. In my capacity as an unauthorized representative of my generation (I am nearly as old as the Charter of African Unity) I often feel wistful and envious. Whenever I come across such national profiles, wishing for the day when my country became confident enough as to tell the whole world about itself in a global publication.
My father’s generation (they who witnessed Africa’s independence) had better luck as they witnessed a brief decade often described as ‘The Golden Age’, when Ethiopia took huge strides in social, political and economic development and was able to have had published
“Nation of Vast Potential and Great Opportunities” in a special section of the Dec. 1, 1963 issue of The New York Times. Capital has obtained a rare original copy of the fortyfive year old special section and has taken the liberty to treat the historic contents, especially in the context of African unity with a pictorial profile of the Founding Fathers of the African body politic. Looming larger than life among the leaders of the 30 then independent nations of Africa was of course, Ethiopia’s Emperor Haile Sellasie I, a towering figure when alive and in death, an everlasting beacon of African Unity. Nearly all of the leaders came from newly independent nations, which attained sovereignty between 1956 and 1963, with the exceptions of Liberia(1889) and Ethiopia, which though invaded on countless occasions, held on to its independence---a fact of history from which Africa’s liberation movements and independence heroes drew inspiration.
The atmosphere most have been electrifying in Africa Hall at midnight of May 25, 1963 as thirty African leaders signed the most important document on the continent. The writer of the article must have entered a journalistic trance, as he observed the excited faces of free Africa-joyous in their declaration to create one entity out of many. The intensity of the conviction and the spirit behind the very wording of the Charter of African Unity makes it clear to us today, forty five years on, that the Charter was more of a plan than a distant vision. It is apparent that the Founding Fathers, even in their worst nightmares of possible failure, did not imagine African unity would not happen within their lifetime, much less almost never, as we have been unfortunate enough to live to tell .
All hope is not gone however, as at the very least, the African Union has not dropped the issue of continental unity altogether. As we write this, the A.U. ministerial pre-summit has put the goal of a pan-Africa government high on the agenda of the Heads of State. It is a bold step and commendable mostly for the spirit of the initiative. Somehow though, at this point in African reality, a union-government sounds more like a vision and less like a plan of action.

Capital extends its appreciation to W/o Tsedale (Moki) Zewdineh for providing a copy of the December 1, 1963 The New York Times that published an advertorial headlined ‘Ethiopia, Nation of Vast Potential and Great Opportunities,’ for our AU special coverage.

Crises dominate

“Industrial Development of Africa”


The transformation of the OAU to the African Union in 2002 was greeted with much fanfare and optimism. Though there was some scepticisim, even die hard Afro-pessimists conceded that the AU marked a significant paradigm shift with regards to conflict prevention and management, thus providing the continent with a plausible chance of solving its myriad problems.
As Heads of State and Government convened here in Addis Ababa from 31st January to 2nd of February 2008 for the 10th AU Ordinary Summit, the organization is at a critical juncture. Almost seven years down the road, the organization has registered mixed results. While the desirability of the organization is not in dispute, its structure and operation have come under intense scrutiny over the years.
While there is consensus that the AU has made plausible steps in enhancing human security on the continent, the persistence of conflict in Chad, Cote d’Ivoire, Somalia and the recent political crisis in Kenya seems to suggest that the AU is still grappling with how to solve the continent’s recurring crisis. This demands introspection from the AU in order to reposition itself if it wants to deal with the turbulence of 2008 and of the years to come. Within this context, one is tempted to ask: Is there a need to re-organize and re-energize the AU, given contemporary African and global political and economic realities?
The 10th AU summit was conducted under the general theme of Industrial Development of Africa. As a point of departure to engage the issues and assess what impact the 10th AU summit will have on the continent’s peace and security agenda, it is imperative that an even more pressing matter be addressed: the question of whether the AU is the panacea to conflict on the continent? Does the AU mandate provide it with the necessary leverage and operational mechanisms to play such a role? The aim here is not to dampen expectation about the AU nor to downplay its achievements.
While the AU states that one of its principal objectives is to promote peace, security, and stability on the continent (Article 3 (f) of the Constitutive Act), this should not be interpreted to mean that the AU is a panacea to conflict on the continent, even despite groundbreaking innovations like Article 4 (h) which reserves to the AU the right to intervene in a member State pursuant to a decision of the Assembly in respect of grave circumstances such as war crimes, genocide and crimes against humanity.
Instead, given the AU’s mandate and governing principle, it seems more appropriate to view the organization as a secondary means of crafting solutions to crises on the continent. There is no doubt that the principal responsibility for peace and security rests within domestic political institutions and leadership. As a consequence, should the AU perhaps prioritize strengthening domestic political institutions, structural conflict prevention strategies, sustain economic integration and robust implementation of its conventions and decisions?
The leaders also discussed peacekeeping missions in Somalia and Sudan’s Darfur region.
Other urgent issues such as Zimbabwe and the Democratic Republic of Congo also remain to be tackled at the summit, which is being attended by more than 40 leaders. Political analysts say that while Africa is attempting to take the lead in solving its own conflicts, it remains constrained by a lack of experience and equipment. The UN Security Council’s permanent members are also reluctant to relinquish control over missions they largely fund. Ban Ki-Moon’s call for greater cooperation between the United Nations and African Union in his inaugural speech is relevant in this context.
So far seven domains of competence have been identified: peace and security, environment and pandemics, trans-national crime, communication/infrastructure, global trade and research/university. There remains disagreement on defense and foreign policy. No agreement has been reached on the institutional implications of these areas of competence. The Ministerial Committee also explored the nature of the relationship between a future Union Government and the Regional Economic Communities (RECs). The Committee did reach agreement on the closer involvement of RECs in AU affairs, with the AU Commission and RECs signing a Protocol governing their relations. The AU assuming responsibility for the external representation and participation of RECs in major global events. Five proposals were made on an appropriate time-frame for a road map without agreement. A similar situation emerged in discussions around alternative and sustainable financing for the Union.
The most critical issue to be tackled by the Summit was the AU Audit Report but the summit postponed the issue. Mandated by the Heads of States during the July Summit, the Audit sought to review the performance of AU organs and RECs in accelerating continental integration. Between September and December, the 14 person High Level Panel held several hearings, studied AU documents and interviewed AU staff, African and non-African embassies. It is expected that the Audit will provide a comprehensive analysis of the performance to date. But the big question is how the AU will act on the Audit Report and how the report will impact on the future of the AU. Does the AU have the capacity and political will to implement the recommendation of the report?
AU experts have also made major cuts on the budget proposals introduced by the organization’s organs, while suggesting that the 2008 budget be maintained at the level of 2007.The situation of refugees, repatriated and displaced persons in Africa will be examined in light of the reports produced by the Commission and the PRC sub-committee on refugees.
Abdoulie Janneh, UN Under-Secretary-General and Executive Secretary of ECA, briefed the Executive Council on the economic situation in Africa, discussed the critical importance of the theme of this Summit, and informed the steps that have been taken to deepen collaboration between the United Nations (UN) and the African Union (AU). He also highlighted how the partnership framework, which both parties agreed, is providing impetus to substantially advance their mutual agenda in several areas, including those encapsulated by the theme of this Summit. Additionally, he briefed the council on how the UN family in Africa, are now working to improve coherence of their activities in support of the AU and its NEPAD program.
On African Economic Performance
The under-secretary-general said in his speech, “I am glad to report that African economies continue to sustain the growth momentum, which has built up in recent years. In 2006, overall real GDP growth rate accelerated from 5.2 percent recorded in 2005 to 5.7 percent. This momentum continues to be underpinned by two main factors. One, the improvement in macroeconomic management in many countries; and two, the strong global demand for key African export commodities, that resulted in high export prices, especially for crude oil, metals and minerals. We are expecting growth in 2007 to continue on this same path and to reach around 5.8 percent”. He added “However, I should stress that despite this trend in economic growth, evidence shows that Africa is unlikely to meet the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) by 2015 unless new and vigorous approaches are adopted. This is why the ECA Conference of Ministers of Finance, Planning and Economic Development scheduled from 29 March to 3 April this year is devoted to the theme of: “Accelerating Africa’s Growth and Development to meet the Millennium Development Goals: Emerging Challenges and the Way Forward”.
The under Secretary General said that he had recently the opportunity to discuss the stalled Doha Round of trade talks with Mr. Pascal Lamy, Director-General of the WTO. Abdoulie Janneh said that he agreed on the need for the speedy resumption of the talks as Africa stands to gain the most from the achievement of a fair and equitable global trading system. With regard to natural resources, a Big Table is to be organized jointly with the African Development Bank (AfDB) immediately after the meeting of the AU Assembly this week. The theme of the Big Table is “Managing Africa’s Natural Resources for Growth and Poverty Reduction”.
On Science and Technology
He further told the gathering that it is therefore clear that for Africa to accelerate its development and achieve the MDGs, African countries have to scale-up their investments in science and technology. And, for this very reason, NEPAD has made science and technology a priority sector for the advancement of the continental agenda. In spite of the tremendous challenges, there is still hope if Africa could take advantage of its great potential. This would require us to:
• Undertake a major Science and Technology Capacity Building Initiative to generate, revamp and deploy large numbers of scientists, engineers and technicians;
• Establish strong linkages between technology-based industry, academia and government needs so that technologies appropriate to national needs are developed; and
• Promote public-private-partnerships in modern science and technology research. Added the secretary general of the UNECA.
AU-China
African Union (AU) Commission Chairperson Alpha Oumar Konare said Tuesday Jan, 2008 that the AU has always attached importance to its cooperation with China. During his talks with visiting Chinese envoy Zhai Jun, Konare spoke highly of the friendly cooperative relations between China and AU and African countries. He said such ties have been developed vigorously following the Beijing Summit of the Forum on China-Africa Cooperation, held in November 2006 and stated the AU will work together with China to further develop Africa-China ties. Zhai, also assistant Minister of Foreign Affairs, extended greetings to Konare from President Hu Jintao and other Chinese leaders.
Zhai hailed the significant role that the AU has played in various aspects, including the maintenance of Africa’s peace and security and the promotion of Africa’s integration process. The Chinese government will continue to support the AU in playing a bigger role in regional and international affairs, he said. Zhai also said the Chinese government will enhance the traditional friendship with Africa and make sure the Chinese and African people will benefit from the results of the China-Africa cooperation. Zhai and his entourage arrived here on Monday. The Chinese delegation, led by Zhai, is attending the 10th AU summit as observer.
On Kenyan crisis
The African Union summit, opened on Thursday, with the UN chief and the AU chairman calling for efforts to find a peaceful way out of the post-election unrest in Kenya that has claimed hundreds of lives. Kenyan President Mwai Kibaki and opposition leader Raila Odinga have a special responsibility to solve the crisis peacefully, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said in his opening address. “I call on the Kenyan people: stop the killings and end the violence now before it’s too late,” he said.
Later, he announced in a press conference that he would meet with both the political rivals in a bid to bolster mediation efforts led by the former UN chief Kofi Annan. Ban is in Nairobi having talks with “Odinga and some representatives of civil society” after meeting Kibaki in Addis Ababa. Addressing the summit, African Union commission chairman Alpha Oumar Konare said the African leaders could not just sit by without being involved in finding a way out of the crisis in Kenya. “If Kenya burns, there will be nothing for tomorrow,” he said. “Tragically, Kenya was the country that always gave to others, offered shelter to others, and talked to them so that they made peace, a country of hope for our continent.”
Japan’s former Prime Minister Yoshiro Mori, who attended the summit as a special guest, voiced his country’s concern over the spiraling crisis, and urged the rival leaders to work together with the African Union and the international community to find a peaceful solution. He pledged 4.1 million dollars in aid to Kenya, where at least a quarter of a million people have been displaced by the violence. Kenyan President Kibaki is attending the summit along with Foreign Minister Moses Wetangula. Wetangula said the continental body has accepted Kibaki as the country’s sole representative at the meeting. ODM Secretary General Anyang Nyongo had urged AU member states not to recognize what he called “the illegitimate and illegal government of Kibaki.”
Darfur
The AU and U.N. have pledged to send a 26,000-strong peacekeeping force to Darfur to replace an undermanned, under-equipped AU force. About a third of that force, which largely incorporates the previous African peacekeepers, has been on the ground since Jan. 1 and has begun to secure the refugee camps. Full deployment of the so-called hybrid force has been delayed because the Sudanese government has been reluctant to accept non-African troops, and the United Nations has not been able to get governments to supply helicopters, which it says are essential for the mission to succeed.The future of the joint force, slated to become the largest peacekeeping operation in the world, is among topics that were discussed at the AU Summit. Nawal Hassan, 45, one of a handful of Darfuri women calling on the African Union to come to their region’s aid, said more soldiers won’t solve the problem. “We need protection, especially for the women,” she said. “We need troops with a strong mandate. We want an international force. What we really need are neutral forces who have no interest with the Sudanese government.”
Other activists complained about soldiers who were unfamiliar with the language and culture, and about the lack of female soldiers and police officers.
Sudan, UN, AU on Darfur
In the other related news, a technical consultative meeting involving the Sudanese government, the United Nations and the African Union (AU) was held here Sunday to discuss ways to complete elements of the UN-AU hybrid peacekeeping operation in Darfur. The meeting, which also discussed the required arrangements for implementation of the operation in the time set, was attended by delegations of the three parties headed by the Undersecretary of the Sudanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Dr. Mutrif Siddiq, UN Under-Secretary General for Peacekeeping Jean-Marie Guehenno and AU Peace and Security Council Commissioner Saeed Djinnit. As well as by the UN-AU Joint Special Representative for Darfur, Rodolphe Adada, and the UNAMID Force Commander, General Martin Luther Agwai.
Sudan’s Envoy to the United Nations, Abdul-Mahmoud Abdul-Halim, said the meeting appreciated the co-operation shown by the Sudanese government and the state authorities in Darfur concerning the implementation of the hybrid operation. He added that the meeting was informed on the implementation of the hybrid operation and the efforts made so far for its success. Abdul-Halim said the tripartite consultative meeting also reviewed pending issues pertinent to the bases for existence of the hybrid operation troops in Sudanese territory and the operation’s action plan. These issues would include the political track, which also covered the political negotiations and the efforts of the UN and the AU in this regard, the track of peace-keeping and deployment of troops, the track of the Sudanese government’s efforts to convey humanitarian aid to the needy citizens and the fourth track of rehabilitation and development.
Kadhafi
Libyan leader Muammar Kadhafi on Tuesday January 29, 2008 warned that Libya could withdraw its investments in Africa and direct them to the Mediterranean if the continent engaged in ‘a racist policy’ or if it decided to ‘neglect its future’. Addressing the international press in his home country, the Libyan leader said if his country injected between 5 billion dollars and 10 billion dollars in the Mediterranean region, it would become the most influential country in that area. After examining Libya’s current investments in Africa, Kadhafi noted that Libyan company, Africa for Investments, had put in about 1 billion dollars while the Libyan national oil company had invested up to 750 million dollars in several African countries. He said that all the monies invested were Libyan funds injected into Africa and given without any strings attached.
“These funds are invested to generate interests for Libyans instead of using them to purchase useless things such as firecrackers, Pepsi Cola or card games,” said the mercurial leader. Members again rejected Moammar Kadhafi’s grand plan to transform the union into a United States of Africa.
The veteran leader of the North African oil exporting nation has long campaigned for a federal African government that can meet the challenges of globalization, fight poverty and resolve conflicts on the continent without interference from the West. Kadhafi lobbied hard for a United States of Africa during an African Union (AU) summit in Ghana last July but the meeting ended with only an agreement to study how it might be created. All 53 AU member countries agree with the goal of African integration but some led by South Africa, a leading power on the continent, say it must be a gradual process.
Disagreements have already emerged over an official language, betraying the scale of the challenges ahead.
Rotating Presidency
Later in the afternoon, Tanzania elected for the rotating presidency at the African Union, announced the outgoing president of Ghana John Kufour in the first day of the meeting of the African Union. ‘I would like to invite our new president, Mr. Jakaya Kikwete,’ said Kufour at the end of the counting of votes. Tanzanian President Jakaya Kikwete won the rotating chairmanship of the African Union on Thursday, succeeding Ghana’s John Kufuor.
An East African country was due to take the AU’s rotating presidency this year. Sudan has failed in its bid assume presidency of the AU for the years 2006 and 2007 after intense international pressure because of human rights abuses by the Sudanese military in the Darfur region and a threat from Chad to withdraw if the nomination was endorsed by AU members. Before this week’s summit, Sudanese delegates said they would support Kikwete for the top job. Women from Darfur and across Africa met ahead of the African Union summit to craft a plan of action for peace in the conflict-torn Darfur region of Sudan.
Assesment of the Union
The Libyan leader Muammar Qadhafi presented a summary of the Report of the high ranking team formed by the AU president to assess the union.
A high-level panel named last year to study the African Union’s operations has concluded that the organization is plagued by waste, corruption, weak leadership and an unhealthy organizational culture. African leaders asked for the high-level audit report last July at their meeting in Accra, Ghana, and named a 13-member panel led by former U.N. Undersecretary-General Adebayo Adedeji of Nigeria.
The panel’s 200-page report was distributed this week. A copy obtained by media is scathingly critical of the organization’s top leadership. It describes the relationship between Commission Chairperson Alpha Omar Konare and other commissioners as ‘dysfunctional’.
The team recommended a haul up of the union’s institutions.
The authors are critical of what they call an ‘unhealthy organizational culture’, crippled by inadequate leadership and weak management systems.
The panel found serious flaws in the operation of several A.U. bodies, and concluded that the overall management of financial resources is in need of a complete overhaul. The report singles out the African Commission on Human and People’s Rights for special criticism, saying that out of a 1.1 million dollar allocation for 2006, only 47,000 dollars was spent on its core mandate.
The audit report was also critical of the A.U. dependency on foreign financing for its operations. Foreign governments currently contribute a substantial amount of the A.U. budget. The panel recommends a tax on airline tickets to finance operations, and urges tough measures against member states who fail to pay their assessed contributions. Twenty one of the 50-plus A.U. member states are currently in arrears on their dues.
The team underlined the ineffectiveness of the summit conference because it is held for two days only, the first is ceremonial and the next delegates start to leave, leaving behind the job to employees.
The team recommended that the executive council be made up of all competences not just foreign ministers. “Therefore an executive council should be formed in Addis Ababa of all competences, and the foreign competence just a member”, the Libyan leader said.
The report notes that states and regions unilaterally form partnerships with Europe and foreign countries.
The team disclosed the poor performance of the African Parliament meaning that it has no role.
The report stressed the inability of regions to achieve any of their objectives, and that their memberships overlap.
The team also recommended to review the authorities and functions of representative committee which include a number of Ambassadors in Addis Ababa and which currently consists of un qualifying people and created problems with the commission.
The report underlined that the authorities of the technical committee and its function is not clear and it recommended to depend on ministerial council and not on such vague committee.
The Leader has called for the cancellation of these technical committees and to be replaced by the ministerial council.
The teams report affirmed the incompetence of the commission which has no authorities and there is a miss understanding of responsibilities and that its relation with the committee of representative is characterising with tensing and mutual distrust.
Qaddafi said that this confirms that there is no reason for the commission.
The team noted in its report the lack of interest of member countries in ratifying the union resolution.
In its report, the team believes the spread of NEPAD systems created a predicament that needs to be solved, it demanded it be integrated in the EU in accordance with Maputo Summit resolutions of 2003, which called for the integration of NEPAD in the AU. Nevertheless some are still enjoying NEPAD and do not want to integrate it, either for personal whims, interest or a conspiracy.
Chairperson
The Summit has also elected a new Chairperson, Deputy Chairperson and Commissioners. Six candidates were vying for the Chairperson’s position, 2 candidates for the Deputy Chairperson’s position, and 58 for Commissioners’ positions. While these individuals operate within an institutional framework there is no doubt that the individual personalities of those elected will have a huge impact on the future of peace and security on the continent. The Summit has also appointed new members of the Peace and Security Council with a two year mandate.
Ghanaian President John Kufuor is the current chairperson of the AU and was elected into the position at the 8th Ordinary Session in January 2007 to serve for the 2007 to 2008 period. Representing Africa’s central eastern region is Antoinette Batumubwira, the current Burundian Minister of External Relations and Cooperation. The South African Development Community (SADC) region has two candidates put forward for the top job of the AU. Former Prime Minister of Swaziland Barnabas Sibusiso Dlamini - who is currently advisor to King Mswati III - served as the country’s finance minister from 1984 to 1993, where after he became an executive director of the International Monetary Fund (IMF). Beginning her career as a lecturer and professor of education at the University of Zambia, Inonge Mbikusita-Lewanika, daughter of King Lewanika II of Barotseland, is one of Zambia’s senior politicians.
Ms Mbikusita-Lewanika, who was elected to parliament in 1991 for the Movement for Multiparty Democracy (MMD), even stood as a presidential candidate in 2001.
Princess Mbikusita-Lewanika served as a regional advisor for Africa in UNICEF, later becoming Zambia’s Ambassador to the United States in 2003 where she currently serves.
Also in the running and representing the Islands of Africa is former President of Mauritius Cassam Uteem. Following Mr Uteem’s long history of involvement in politics as both a youth leader and social worker, he was nominated as Councillor of the City of Port Louis in 1969 where he remained for several years becoming Lord Mayor in 1986.
Mr Uteem was elected president in 1992 and served out two five year terms until his resignation in 2002. The former president is also a member of the exclusive Club of Madrid, an independent organisation promoting the global process of democratisation.
From Africa’s western tip, Dr Abdulai Osman Conteh - who has served as vice-president, minister of foreign affairs and finance, as well as Attorney-General and minister of justice - is representing Sierra Leone.
Possessing a multitude of degrees in law and international affairs, Dr Conteh has over 10 years of practice in law as both a private practitioner and a government lawyer, served for over 10 years as minister of foreign affairs and diplomacy. The last of the six candidates for chairperson, Jean Ping, has been the Foreign Minister of Gabon since 1999 and has served in various portfolios of government minister of information, mines and hydrocarbons, finance, environment and tourism, amongst others. A highlight of Mr Ping’s extensive political career was his election as president of the 59th Session of the UN General Assembly in 2004. Dr Deng, a Pretoria-based researcher, highlighted that it is apparent the AU is moving from its days of philosophical governance to an organization based on a more “hands-on” managerial approach to oversight.
“[The former chairperson] Prof Konaré would argue that it is not the organs of the AU that fail to function but the mandate of the AU itself.
“Konaré did not stay in office for a second term because he argued that the chairperson does not have the mandate to control the commission, and therefore that the AU needs to revisit the structures of the Union itself.
Gabon’s Foreign Minister Jean Ping was elected to a four-year term as chairperson of the African Union Commission Friday, replacing the charismatic former president of Mali, Alpha Oumar Konare. Ping is a career civil servant who previously served as President of the United Nations General Assembly.
African diplomats say Ping’s election, and the choice a day earlier of Tanzanian President Jakaya Kikwete to fill the rotating A.U presidency is aimed at giving a fresh start to an organization criticized in a recent internal audit as being riven by weak leadership, and an unhealthy organizational structure.
After his election, the new chairperson stood in the jam-packed assembly hall alongside an obviously proud Gabonese President Omar Bongo, Africa’s longest serving head of state, who helped to engineer the election.
Elected vice-chairperson was Kenyan Erastus Mwencha, the secretary-general of COMESA, the Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa. Despite the political turmoil gripping his country, Kenyan president Mwai Kibaki stayed to see through Mwencha’s candidacy.
The summit also turned its attention Friday to another crisis brewing in Africa, this one in Chad. Several delegates voiced fears that an offensive underway by rebels around the Chadian capital, Ndjamena, could damage efforts to end fighting in neighboring Sudan.
Day two of the summit also dealt a fresh blow to a proposal by Libyan leader Moammar Gaddafi to immediately establish a union government that would lead to creation of a United States of Africa.
The Gaddafi proposal received a cool reception when it was introduced at last July’s A.U. summit in Accra, Ghana. Delegates at this gathering decided to send the plan to committee for further study. But Mr. Gaddafi said afterward he is not giving up hope.
Many African leaders attending the summit say they agree the Gaddafi proposal has merit, and is likely to win eventual approval.
Leaders also delayed action on the controversial internal audit. Diplomats say a meeting of foreign ministers is likely in a few months take up the questions of institutional reform.
The three-day summit wraps up Saturday with a final brief session and issuance of a joint communiqué.